m2powered logo

 


about usservicesbuzz

 

writing samples

go to daily star

Guest Opinion: Pay discrimination against women endures
By Michael Mandel
Arizona Daily Wildcat
Tucson, Arizona | Published: 06.25.2007

Arizona does a better job than most states in compensating women fairly and equally, but anything short of full equality is unacceptable.

According to the U.S. Census Bureau, women earned 77 percent of what men earned in 2005 nationally, on average, for performing substantially equal work. The picture is moderately better in Arizona, which ranks second in the nation for our earnings ratio: Arizona women earn 83.8 percent of what Arizona men earn.

The pay gap has closed considerably nationwide since 1982. Still, at the current rate of closing the gap, women will have to wait until 2057 to earn equal pay, according to the Institute for Women's Policy Research. The American Association of University Women reports that Arizona women fared slightly better than women in most other states, gaining about 14 percent from 1989 to 2005.

Pay inequality has been well-documented for decades and prompted Congress to pass the Equal Pay Act in 1963 and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act in 1964. The latest federal effort to address pay inequality, the Fair Pay Act, has been floating around Congress since 1994.

Thanks to a disastrous May 29 decision by the U.S. Supreme Court, Congress may have renewed motivation to finally pass new legislation that guarantees fair and equal pay for equal work.

I won't hold my breath. While we wait for Congress to debate war funding and other matters of national importance, women continue to suffer the consequences of not being fairly compensated for their work. And thanks to the male majority on the Supreme Court, women have fewer opportunities to seek reparation for this discrimination.

BusinessWeek magazine reports in its June 18 issue that the Supreme Court's decision is "impractical and a death knell to many compensation lawsuits."

In what is becoming a routine 5-4 split, the Supreme Court ruled that pay discrimination claims made under Title VII must be filed within 180 days of discriminatory pay adjustments. The case in question was that of Lilly M. Ledbetter, a nearly 20-year supervisor at Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co., who made significantly less than her male counterparts, including some with less experience.

Goodyear had a well-documented habit of discriminating against women. One of Ledbetter's female colleagues actually earned less than a man she supervised. The discrimination had nothing to do with performance, either. Ledbetter received a "top performance" award the year before she left Goodyear.

Noticeable pay discrimination develops over time, as small discrepancies early in one's career become additive as time wears on. Pay discrimination based on sex becomes more pronounced over time because pay increases are calculated as a percentage of current salary.

I am proud to serve on the Pima County/Tucson Women's Commission. We adopted a position statement last September that affirms our commitment to achieving pay equity. We support equality of treatment in all aspects of employment and oppose discrimination based on gender or any other protected status.

In 2005, working with the Tucson Chapter of the National Association of Women Business Owners, we recognized several local businesses with awards for their commitment to pay equity.

The Supreme Court's decision ought to serve as a rallying cry for all of us, women and men, that pay discrimination is real, pervasive and must be eliminated. Let's continue to reward companies that treat women fairly and equally, and let's investigate, expose and punish those companies that persist in denying equal pay for equal work.

Boycotting Goodyear tires is a good place to start.

Write to Michael Mandel at michael@m2powered.com.


go to wildcat

Guest Commentary: The real facts about assault
By Michael Mandel
Arizona Daily Wildcat
September 2, 2005

Scott Patterson came so close to hitting the mark with his Aug. 29 editorial, "Would you feel safe if you had a whistle?"

He starts out strong, but fails to make a rational point when he minimizes the prevalence and impact of sexual assaults. The University of Arizona Police Department statistics he cites for the number of sexual assaults reported each year are definitely low, especially compared with the department's statistics for theft.

The low sexual assault numbers he cites only account for those assaults that happened on campus that were reported to law enforcement. A significant number of UA community members were sexually assaulted off campus, and those assaults are not included in the numbers that were cited.

Many assaults go unreported; this is supported by the U.S. Department of Justice statistic that only 38.5 percent of sexual assaults against people age 12 or older were reported to law enforcement in 2003. The University of Arizona's Oasis Program for Sexual Assault and Relationship Violence and the Southern Arizona Center Against Sexual Assault receive thousands of calls every year from people in this community who are in crisis as a result of being sexually assaulted.

We provide mental health services to hundreds of those rape survivors and their loved ones to help mitigate the long-term trauma of sexual violence. We work independently and collaboratively to prevent the violence from being perpetrated in the first place.

Adding to the complexity of the issue, most young people who experience violence that meets the legal definition of sexual assault never label the experience as such.

They reject the sexual assault label and then wander around for months or years wondering where their trauma symptoms are coming from. They are literally the walking wounded, and few of them are linking the effects with the cause. This raises the second point Patterson missed entirely. Sexual violence can cause profound psychological, physical and emotional trauma that may take years to integrate. Survivors can carry symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder, a diagnosis shared by war veterans returning from combat.

These symptoms may include depression, anxiety, anger and flashbacks. This trauma often leads to dropping out, addiction, job loss and the loss of support systems like family and services.

Comparing the trauma of sexual assault to the trauma of robbery is like comparing open-heart surgery to a skinned knee. Even when accounting for the different reporting rates between the two crimes, the life-altering impact of sexual assault is clearly disproportionate to the impact of a robbery.

While theft may involve an invasion of personal space and property, sexual assault is an invasion of the body, the psyche and the spirit.

Even if the statistics only reflected that one person was sexually assaulted, that is still a significant reason to dedicate resources to prevention and intervention. Many of the rape survivors with whom we work would gladly exchange their CD collections if it meant they could get their lives back to the point they were at before they were assaulted.

Theft and other property crimes are of course a concern on any campus and in every community, but minimizing the experiences of rape survivors does a tremendous disservice to those survivors and to future victims.

The campus community deserves to be informed about this silent epidemic and ought to be encouraged to speak up and end that silence.

We agree that the orientation program on crime should be made mandatory again, but that the program must continue to place sexual violence at the top of the syllabus.

Michael Mandel is community projects manager at the Southern Arizona Center Against Sexual Assault.

Tina Tarin, the Violence Prevention Specialist for the UA's Oasis Program, and Michelle Dorsey, the Psychologist for the UA's Oasis Program contributed to this commentary.

 

 

index

This page features samples of Michael's written published work. Click on a headline below to jump to that article.




about us | services | buzz | home

copyright © 2005 | e-mail me

   
 

news

  • blog
  • writing samples

  • qualifications

  • resumé (pdf)

  • web design

  • v-day tucson
  • ♀'s commission
  • project safe place
  • take back the night
  • webelieveher (news)

  • links

  • huffington post
  • daily kos
  • my dd
  • talking points memo
  • rockridge institute
  • longview institute